The Pittsburgh Pirates' Third Base Dilemma: A Deep Dive into Valdez's Role
The Pittsburgh Pirates are gearing up for the upcoming season, but their third base depth remains a concern. With just Jared Triolo boasting significant MLB experience at the position, the Pirates are in a tricky situation. Enter Enmanuel Valdez, a player who might just be the key to filling this gap.
Valdez, who has been working on infield drills at third base, is the likely starting third baseman for the Pirates on Opening Day. While he hasn't played much third base at the major league level, his extensive experience in the minors and the Pirates' limited options make him a crucial piece of the puzzle.
The Pirates have been actively seeking third basemen through free agency and trades, but so far, no additions have been made. This leaves Valdez as a potential savior, despite his limited major league experience at the position.
Why Valdez is a Third Base Option
Third base is a position of weakness for the Pirates, with only Triolo having substantial MLB experience. Jack Brannigan, the only other true third baseman on the 40-man roster, is recovering from a season-ending injury. Nick Gonzales and Nick Yorke, on the other hand, have barely played third base professionally, leaving Valdez as the only other viable option.
Valdez's Minor League Experience
Valdez's minor league numbers tell a different story. He has started 139 of 145 games at third base in the minors, showcasing his comfort and skill at the position. While he has played most of his major league time at second base, his time at third base is crucial for the Pirates' depth.
Valdez's First Season with the Pirates
Valdez joined the Pirates in a trade with the Boston Red Sox, bringing in right-handed pitcher Joe Vogatsky. He made his Pirates debut on March 28, 2025, replacing Nick Gonzales, who suffered a displaced left ankle fracture on Opening Day. Valdez primarily played first base due to injuries to Endy Rodríguez and Spencer Horwitz.
In his first season, Valdez slashed .209/.294/.363 for an OPS of .657 in 31 games. He accumulated 19 hits in 91 at-bats, four doubles, two triples, two home runs, 12 RBI, and 11 walks while striking out 16 times.
Injury Concerns and Recovery
Valdez's season took a turn when he was placed on the 10-day Injured List on May 9 due to left shoulder inflammation. He was then transferred to the 60-day Injured List on May 14, undergoing surgery ahead of May 21. This injury sidelined him for six months, but he eventually returned to action.
Valdez's Return and Winter League Play
After his recovery, Valdez joined the Estrellas Orientales in the Dominican Winter League for 10 games and then played two games with Criollos de Caguas in the Puerto Rican Winter League. His return to action is a positive sign for the Pirates, who are in dire need of depth at third base.
The Pirates' Third Base Future
With Valdez's return and the team's ongoing search for third basemen, the Pirates are in a better position to address their depth concerns. While Valdez's major league experience at third base is limited, his minor league prowess and the team's current situation make him a key player in the Pirates' quest for a stronger third base presence.
