Is Scott Robertson’s All Blacks Tenure on Thin Ice? A Deep Dive into Year Two and the Road Ahead
By Liam Napier, Senior Sports Journalist, NZ Herald
Published: 5 Dec, 2025 03:00 AM · 11 mins read
Here’s the hard truth: Despite a 74% win rate in 2026, Scott Robertson’s second year at the helm of the All Blacks feels less like progress and more like stagnation. But here’s where it gets controversial—is this enough for a team that’s historically set the bar for rugby excellence? Let’s break it down.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
On paper, Robertson’s All Blacks won 10 out of 13 tests in 2026—a statistic that, in isolation, might seem respectable. Yet, dig deeper, and the narrative shifts. With just one fewer loss than his debut season, the margin for improvement appears alarmingly slim. And this is the part most people miss: while depth has grown in certain areas, the team’s strategic, tactical, and performance levels are plateauing. In rugby, standing still is the same as moving backward.
Strategic Stagnation: The Elephant in the Room
Robertson’s tenure has raised eyebrows among fans and analysts alike. Despite the All Blacks’ storied legacy, their gameplay under his leadership lacks the innovation and dominance we’ve come to expect. For instance, their humbling loss at Twickenham wasn’t just a defeat—it was a stark reminder of the team’s vulnerabilities. Are these growing pains of a new coach, or signs of a deeper issue?
What’s Next for New Zealand Rugby?
As the sophomore season wraps up, New Zealand Rugby faces a critical question: Is Robertson the right man to lead the All Blacks back to the pinnacle of the sport? While first-year jitters are understandable, year two should have shown clearer signs of growth. Instead, the team’s performance feels incremental at best, leaving fans wondering if a coaching shake-up is on the horizon.
A Controversial Take: Is Change Inevitable?
Here’s a thought-provoking question: Can the All Blacks reclaim their throne under Robertson’s current approach, or is a fresh perspective needed? Some argue that his style, while effective in Super Rugby, doesn’t translate to the test arena. Others believe he needs more time. What’s your take? Let’s spark a debate in the comments—agree or disagree, the future of the All Blacks hangs in the balance.
Final Thoughts
Scott Robertson’s second year as All Blacks coach has been a mixed bag. While there are glimmers of hope, the lack of significant progress raises concerns. As we look ahead, one thing is clear: New Zealand Rugby must decide whether to double down on Robertson’s vision or explore new avenues. The clock is ticking—and the rugby world is watching.
